Summary of Show: “Arsenic and Old Lace” is set in 1941, and revolves around the antics of the delightfully insane Brewster family. Abby and Martha are two incredibly charitable sisters, who view poisoning lonely men with no living family members as an act of charity. They find their victims by posting that they have a room for rent in their Victorian home, which they share with their nephew Teddy, who believes that he is Theodore Roosevelt. The action begins when their other nephew, Mortimer, comes to visit and finds a body in the window seat. The excitement ensues when the third nephew, Jonathan, returns to the Brewster home with his personal “plastic surgeon” after years of being on the lamb for his criminally insane acts. Several other characters are sprinkled into the action, including police officers, ministers, and Mortimer’s sweetheart, Elaine. After several hilarious scenes full of dead bodies being moved back and forth, lights switching on and off, and threats and accusations flying all through the house, the fates of Jonathan, Teddy, and the Brewster aunts are decided and Mortimer discovers a secret that puts his mind at ease about marrying Elaine. Everything is resolved, until…

Arsenic and Old Lace Cast

Abby Brewster – Missy Handwerker
Martha Brewster – Kelly Stevenson
Mortimer Brewster – Adam Hogue
Teddy Brewster – Daniel Mullins
Jonathan Brewster – Jamison White
Dr. Einstein – Rob Koch
Elaine Harper – Emily Chateau 
Officer Klein – Ian Eubanks
Officer Brophy – Nathaniel White
Reverend Dr. Harper - Bobby Chamberlin 
Officer O’Hara – Hayden Montgomery
Lieutenant Rooney – Phillip Frazier
Mr. Gibbs – Russell Dorris
Mr. Witherspoon – John Frye